|
muk1's Super Columbine Massacre RPG (PC)
|
| [October 28, 2010 09:48:17 AM]
|
So today is my last day of playing Super Columbine and I reached the part in the library where I am shooting different students. In the game, Dylan asks a "religious girl" if she believes in God before killing her. I found this to be completely disturbing and unethical. The entire game is unethical but this part made me almost disgusted playing it. The game got really graphic and showed victims families crying and I guess it sort of visually showed me what happened at the Columbine shootings but I would not have liked to have seen it that way.
The end of the game is stupid. The two boys go outside and start shooting at police officers before they kill themselves. Then, the game takes the two boys to hell where they fight random characters from older games. I thought this level was extremely random and unfitting the mood of the rest of the game. Even if the creater made this game to be in any way "educational" or to at least teach players about what happened in the massacre, it did not do its job with this round. It almost seemed like the creater put this in just to make the game more playable. Although, it wasn't that fun anyway.
The entire creation of the game was immoral but the last round was the worst. Based on Kant's first Categorical Imperative, we can create a rule: It is okay to make disturbing games for anyone to play as long as the last level is fun. If we universalize this, it would say everyone should make disturbing games with the last level the funnest. This is self-defeating because if everyone made disturbing games with only the last level being fun, no one would really want to buy games anymore because the entire game would not be fun until the end. Therefore, video game creation companies would lose money and people would be unhappy without video games.
add a comment 
|
| [October 27, 2010 10:20:11 AM]
|
This is my second time playing the game and I still could not really figure out what I was supposed to do to make the game progress more. The characters and music seemed pretty good quality. Although, the game really erked me with the conversation between Dylan and Eric. It seemed like the creators of the game tried to really make it controversial and put in what they thought the killers may have talked about privately. This game is clearly crying for attention and does not really feel like a game while your playing it, well at least for me it didn't. I do not like violent games and it almost seemed like a mockery of the actual Columbine shootings. It seemed pretty real and well-depicted but it was not fun because while I was playing I thought about how a person could possibly get enjoyment out of the game and not think about what it is based on.
This entry has been edited 1 time. It was last edited on Oct 27th, 2010 at 10:20:33.
add a comment
|
| [October 27, 2010 09:44:54 AM]
|
For my first time playing this game I was pretty bored. I went around shooting all of the students and this seemed a little hasty to me. I feel that it is games like this that make society question violent video games as a whole. The game seemed like a pretty good depiction of the Columbine Massacre; although, it was not educational in making people understand what the poor students had to deal with. Rather, the game turns you into a vicious killer of innocent students.
I did notice a slight gender motif with women regaining strength through prayer but men tried to fight back. None of the students really tried to run, no matter what gender. Instead, they just carried on with their regular routine while they were shot at.
I don't think it was ethical to even create such a game. According to rule utilitarianism, if everyone were creating games with depictions of violent events many people would be effected. Society would have a negative outlook on it because the game can cause people to have the wrong idea of what is okay to play or not. I'm sure that the families of people murdered or hurt in the shooting would not be pleased to see a game like this. Also, parents of young children who somehow find this game on the internet and play it would not be happy because the children may not understand that it is bad to find fun out of someone else's peril. Overal, it would cause more unhapiness then hapiness to people who play it, their families, and families of victims from the shooting. Therefore, the creation of the game itself was unethical.
add a comment
|
